Aluminium
An Ecologically Sound Material?
Aluminium has in the past had
a reputation as an environmentally
poor material. This
unfortunately arose during the
recent fixation with the
measurement of embodied energy of
a material as an indication of its
environmental impact. This
has proved overly simplistic and
in many cases erroneous.
Aluminium has been described as
"congealed energy"
and given bad press but a detailed
analysis of the broadscale
lifecycle
environmental impact and benefits
of the use of the metal provides a
starkly different view. The
following broadsheet details the
environmental review of aluminium
alloys carried out for the
ecoshelta project.
Information
Broadsheet
Prepared by
Stephen Sainsbury architect.
Referencing
Capral Aluminium’s EcoMetal
publications, The EcoCost
ecological
impact rating system and associated
documented research findings, The Centre for
Mined Land Re-Habilitation at UQ,
and EPA monitoring reports, and a
number of industry monitoring sites, the
following analysis of the use of Aluminium structural alloy in the
building material palette are
discussed.
Most Aluminium
for Australian use is mined in this
country and is subject to
the stringent environmental controls
of the EPA.
The Bauxite
ore is extracted in a surface mining
operation using a regeneration
program which results in a high
quality post mining rehabilitation
outcome. Vegetation in the path of
the strip mining process is seed
stripped and those amenable species
are potted up and held in nursery
conditions nearby. The top soil is
stripped and winrowed, the subsoil
is stripped and windrowed. The
overburden is removed and stored.
The bauxite ore is stripped and
taken to the processing site.
The
overburden is replaced, the subsoil
is replaced and then the topsoil
replaced. The nurseried plants are
re-planted and the area overseeded
with treated native and endemic
seedstock. Within five to ten years
the land is returned to a high
quality restored ecosystem capable
of regenerating to original status.
The
extracted ore is processed to
Alumina which is shipped for processing into aluminium. The initial refinement
process consumes considerable energy
and produces quantities of red mud
waste which is difficult to
rehabilitate. Current research
programs have been successful in
washing with seawater then capping
these residues in topsoil and
revegetating.
The Alumina
is smelted into Aluminium at the
refinery, a process which
consumes considerable energy and
while having low environmental
pollutant output due to its
electrolytic nature produces some
by-products.
Through
ongoing process research and
refinement, CO2 emissions and other
pollutant output have been reduced
over the last decade by 82%. The
environmental output of the process
is still undergoing review and
refinement to reduce these levels
even further. This can be compared
to the steel mining industries
almost negligible improvements over
the last three decades in both
mining and processing.
Aluminium
can be recycled using only 5% of the
energy requirements and none of the
pollutant output of the original
smelting process. Aluminium is
widely re-cycled currently, with
between 15 and 25% of all aluminium
now on the market coming from
recycling. Collection agencies and
collection systems are widespread
and in place, ensuring easy and
simple recycling.
Aluminium has a very long life
due to its unusual property of
forming a protective "skin"of nearly
invisible impenetrateable oxide
which prevents further corrosion.
Over 90% of all aluminium every
refined into metal is still in use
today, compared with an estimated
5-10% of steel.
Extrusion
and forming of aluminium elements is
a low energy process with much
material not requiring recasting.
Aluminium
can be alloyed with a wide array of
other metals to create alloys with a
range of properties for different
uses. Very strong, highly corrosion
resistant alloys are available for
specification in construction.
Aluminium is
extremely light and strong. Half the
weight and four to five times the
strength of steel, Kg for Kg. This
means in any given situation less
than half the weight of material is
required. As environmental impact in
terms of transport, pollutant
emissions, energy usage and so on
are all based on the mass of
material required to perform the
given task, the light weight of the
material has critical environmental advantages.
Much less
material is required to perform the
same structural and cladding tasks.
The material
can be handled in factories and on
site without the need for heavy
lifting machinery and the extra
energy costs or environmental impact
associated with those requirements.
A six metre long, 215x80mm I Beam can
easily be lifted by two people. On
site erection of large scale frames
is substantially easier, cheaper and
safer than steel or other large span
systems, requiring much less energy.
Cutting and
shaping can be done with normal
builder's power tools using special
blades, without the need for hot gas
or laser cutting at very low energy
cost.
Fabrication
using MIG and TIG welding can be
done on low energy settings creating
strong permanent, predicatable
weatherproof and corrosion resistant
bonding. Latest technology allows on
site fabrication to be done safely, cheaply and testably.
Aluminium is
naturally corrosion resistant due to
its unusual surface self coating
properties. It does not require
surface treatments, priming,
painting or protection from the
elements. Welds are stable and self
protecting ensuring long term
reliability. A range of surface
patinas can be created using
mechanical post fabrication
techniques.
Aluminium
has a high surface reflectivity in
the Infra Red spectrum up to 70% of
all incident heat is reflected with
only moderate visible light glare.
These properties can be used to
substantially improve the thermal
performance of building elements
An EcoCost
analysis taking into account all of
these factors gives a environmental
impact value for aluminium of less
than a quarter for that of steel and
considerably less than that for
plantation timber to perform the
same task. In any situation
where minimal impact materials such
as rammed earth and site milled
timber are not available, Aluminium
Alloys rapidly become the least
environmentally harmful and most
flexible material available.
Home
|